This
is why you have to get involved
Coverage of a security certificate case by: Mohamed S.
Kamel
Jun 15, 2003
[Those new laws and unjust treatment
we are speaking about are in Canada, and not in a third world country, this
shameful laws coming into effect thanks the Canadian’s solicitor general,
minister of immigration, the Canadian Intelligence Services CSIS, and the
Media]
Do
you know that under the security certificate,
secret evidence could be used against you, which neither you nor your lawyer is
allowed to know, and condemn you with no right to appeal?
CSIS
seems to believe every Muslim or Arab is a sleeper and you just have to push a
button and they become a terrorist, that is the same what is the Zionist
movement are spreading as part of the Islamophobia and Anti-Arab propaganda,
and that is what the main mission of people like Daniel Pipe, one of the main
players of Bush administration and the God father of many of the right wing
politician in Canada.
Some
people did understand that from the experience of Adil Charkaoui and his family
and started to work in a group to defend Adil rights for justice. As stated by
“La Press” a French Newspaper from Montreal under the banner read “Justice for
Adil Charkaoui” people met to hear the story of the Moroccan 30 years old Adil Charkaoui
and his family who moved to Canada in 1995 dreaming of a
good life in a nice country governed by justice and law.
Adil
is married has an 18 month old daughter and his wife is 6 month pregnant.
Educated in a variety of schools including a Jewish school, he is a French teacher
doing his masters in University of Montreal. He was arrested in 21 May 2003 by
the RCMP (Canadian Police) for no crime, but a Security Certificate issued in
16 May 2003 by the Solicitor General and the Minster of Immigration upon
recommendation by the CSIS branded him a threat to national security. Notice
this is the same CSIS who’s credibly has been questioned by allegations in the
Air India Affair and others.
In an Information session hold May 31st
2003 names of the people detained under this security certificate have been
reminded by: Mohamed Mahgoub since 2000, Mohamed Harakat since Dec. 2002,
Mahmoud Gab Allah since 1999 and now Adil Charkoui that was not the only threat
to the Arab and Muslim, this came in addition to the daily discrimination, the
daily media propaganda and the campaign of deportation of the Algerian and
Palestinian refugees.
In this event that has been organized
by the Justice Coalition For Adil Charkaoui, a coalition of many organizations
and individuals, among them the Muslim Council of Montreal (MCM), Voice of
Conscience, Home not Bomb from Toronto.
Abdel-Salam Elminyawy the president of the MCM said that how we can
trust CSIS while one of their agents identified as
David: dose not know the population of Egypt, dose not know what countries are
located in North Africa and thinks that Iran is an Arabic Country, Mr.
Elminyawi explained that his law is a real threat to Canadian Security because
with injustice people will not help the security agents. He called upon the
Media to be honest and not to expose the people personal life and their
families. To stop the propaganda by accusing him of being an Al-Qaieda member
because he is Muslim, visited Pakistan and he teaches self-defense to Muslims.
And from No one Illegal, Mr. Emanuel
said that they are in solidarity with every Canadian facing discrimination, and
he denounce the unjust arrest and the unfair trial, explaining how the USA and
Canada stand by considering the Palestinian resistance terrorism while it is
against the occupation and the state terrorism, this stand is ill moral and
that the discrimination against Muslim and Arab mad theme a escape goat to keep
the all the society afraid so that the security agents can increase their
budget.
Mohamed Shaleby from Non Status Algerian
explain how the Algerian case been partially solved for 80% if them by believe
and hard work, and who Canada became a country that dose not support human
rights it is only looking for business.
On CSIS’ way of handling security issue, Mr. RIAD
SALOOJEE the executive director of the CAIR-CAN Council on American-Islamic
Relations said in the Globe and Mail on his article “CSIS warrants contravene
rule of law”:
“….it will be impossible to know
whether Montreal resident Adil Charkaoui, who has been recently accused of
being a member of an Al-Qa'ida sleeper cell, is innocent or guilty…”
“…All Canadians should be
concerned about terrorists in our midst. There is, as well, another reason why
Canadians ought to be concerned with the Charkaoui case and with many other
similar cases before the courts: the rule of law.
Security-certificate cases are
anything but transparent. Certificates are frequently issued by the immigration
minister or the solicitor-general through a murky process with no parliamentary
oversight. Individuals are sometimes branded as terrorists on the basis of
dubious evidence obtained from sources - a litany of non-democratic countries,
for example - that are, at best, problematic.
The politicized nature of these
certificates is frankly acknowledged by former CSIS agent Michel Juneau-Katsuya
who noted that the Charkaoui's arrest "may have been done as a pre-emptive
strike or to destabilize a network, or it may have been done under pressure to
please the Americans.
Assuming that there is some evidence,
however, Charkaoui will be still be batting blind because he and his lawyer
will not be shown the heart of the evidence against him. On this lack of
transparency, Juneau-Katsuya is equally candid: Because the majority of
evidence is never disclosed, Charkaoui will be left to defend himself in the
dark…”
“…Charkuoui's assertion, that he
has been pinpointed because he rejected the overtures from CSIS to spy on the
community, is also worthy of scrutiny. There have been numerous complaints
against CSIS of late, all reported in the media. For example, CSIS requesting
that Egyptian intelligence detain a Toronto imam who was en route to Canada;
recent stories about CSIS's rather active and aggressive recruitment drive in
the Algerian community; and CSIS involvement in the deportation of Canadian
Maher Arar to Syria.
Toronto lawyer Clayton Ruby
argues that, "Crimes are committed in a casual and routine way by
CSIS." In fact, for a long list of CSIS's rather shadowy workings, see the
book Covert Entry by investigative reporter Andrew Mitrovica. It's an
eye-opening plot of illegal entry, tax evasion, destruction of evidence,
illegal eavesdropping, theft and fraud. For starters…”
On Globe and Mail and under the title “When liberties
fall in security's name” the point concerning the counter terrorism practices
“…Little of this
reassures those concerned about civil liberties. While we want to presume the
good faith of the authorities, they are not immune to overzealous, misguided
actions. The minor cases that have trickled into the criminal, and thus public,
courts are instructive.
Consider Tarek
Adealy Khafagy, a hapless Montreal baker of Egyptian origin arrested in 2000 by
RCMP agents acting on a tip. He was accused of plotting to blow up the Israeli
consulate. Mr. Khafagy spent five months behind bars until he was acquitted. It
turned out that the Mounties' informant owed $6,000 (U.S.) to Mr. Khafagy and
thought framing him would be a way to get rid of a creditor.
In Mr. Jaballah's
case, Justice Mac- Kay's ruling repeatedly spoke of an abuse of process because
of the way the Immigration Department didn't respond promptly to his
application for protection from possible torture or death if he were deported
to Egypt.
The lack of
safeguards when secret evidence is heard is troubling enough that Mr. Justice
James Hugessen last year went public about the way he and others on the Federal
Court feel. "We hate it," he said. "We do not like this process
of having to sit alone, hearing only one party and looking at the materials
produced by only one party."
On
Globe and Mail and under the title “Immigrant is al-Qaeda agent, CSIS says” TU THANH HA wrote:
"…The service
is of the opinion that Charkaoui fits the profile of a
sleeper agent who
could be activated at any time," one CSIS filing said.
The documents say
that CSIS agents have been monitoring Mr. Charkaoui for a while but moved to
detain him now because of this spring's war in Iraq, during which Iraqi
Information Minister Mohammed Saeed al-Sahhaf called on Muslims everywhere to
wage holy war against the U.S.-British coalition…”
“…The synopsis that was made public yesterday
omits key information, leaving the impression that Mr. Charkaoui's main sin is
that he taught karate and that he knew Muslim people who subsequently turned
out to be terror suspects...”
On a press release
The Canadian Arab Federation (CAF) called the ‘Security
Certificates’ an insult to Canadians and called for a major overhaul of the
current practice that allows, under the Immigration and Refugee protection act,
for the detention and eventual expulsion of certain individuals based on a
ministerial certificate.
“…A
‘Security Certificate’ was used in Montreal last week to detain a 30-year-old
Moroccan-born man, Adil Charkaoui, on suspicion he is connected to
terrorists. Another man, Mahmoud
Jaballah, an Egyptian-born with 4 children, has spent 22 months in solitary
confinement in a Toronto cell on similar suspicions. “It is un-Canadian to hold someone without
charges or proof of guilt. This flies against the basic rules of justice…”
CAF calls for a new process that
allows for evidence to be challenged while allaying fears over national
security. “Judges need to hear both
sides of the story and have the benefit from cross-examination of the evidence.
This is how justice in a civilized society is served…”
The Canadian Muslim Forum (CMF) in its press release called Mr.
Charkaoui’s unjust treatment is an insult to Canadian values and that the arrest
by a “secret certificate” a fall out of the Islamophobia and anti-Arab
propaganda, therefore the CMF invokes the “charter of rights and freedom”;
henceforth the right of the accused for a due process.
Canada's
national security has always been and continues to be ensured by Canada's
systems of Law and Order, therefore all Canadians, regardless of ethnicity and
religion, are equally protected under the Canadian law.
Canada's
charter “of rights and freedom” guarantees the civil rights of all Canadians
under the law of the land, therefore every Canadian citizen or permanent
resident is entitled to a protection against self-incrimination, secret
evidence, and racial profiling and have the right for a due process.
Mr.
Charkaoui's case was handled, by certain media, with racism linking him to its
Arab origin and to Al- Qaida, and he was unjustly served a “security
certificate” denying him access to a due processes every other Canadian or
permanent resident.
The CMF
considers the unjust treatment of Mr. Charkaoui insulting to the Canadian
socio-democratic values; equality and justice.
The CMF
condemns the media discrimination and the security mistreatment of any
Canadian, regardless of race, ethnicity or religion, and invokes the “charter
of rights and freedom” and calls for the abolition of all non-regular laws and
procedures.
In a joined press release the “La Ligue des droits et libertés”, Amnesty
International – Canada, the American Association for Justice and the Coalition
for the international monitoring of the civil liberty denounce the Canadian Government
using of the “Security Certificate” to arrest and detain Adil Charkaoui…”
“…this certificate that designed to protect the national security became a
threat to the rights and the freedom..”
“… The procedure under this Security Certificate is
in contrary to the rule of fundamental justice…”
“…The application of this certificate would result
of a deportation of a refuge or an immigrant to his native country where he
could be terture or even killed...”
Adil
Charkoui's defense lawyer Rocco Galati said it's unacceptable that his client
is in jail without knowing details of the case against him. "If they have
the evidence, why don't they charge him under the Criminal Code?" "This is the
same process we saw in France before the revolution with “lettres de cachet”,
and it's the same process we used during the Second World War against Japanese
and Italian Canadians who were interned." "It is medieval"
"We've reverted to a pre-English Bill of Rights, a pre-French Revolution
system of royal rule and no constitutional rights whatsoever where we can
decide these things in secret," he stated.
Generally the fear
became part of the Muslim and Arab lifes, and Canadian
generally are
feeling less secure, as stated by Mr. Yahya Abdul Rahman, the editor of the
online Montreal Muslim News Network in his article “As a Canadian CSIS makes me
feel less secure and its' pontification about "national security" is
disingenuous”
“…We are asked to
trust them because if they publicly reveal what evidence they have against Mr. Charkaoui,
the security of Canadians would be compromised…”
“…The problem is that this method does not
provide for the proper checks and balances embedded in usual criminal
proceedings here in Canada. How do we
know the authorities are not acting on prejudice or making many mistakes? …”
“…The Canadian
Charter of Rights and Freedoms states that " Everyone has the right on
arrest or detention to be informed promptly of the reasons therefore" and
also in section 11 everyone has the right " to be presumed innocent until
proven guilty according to law in a fair and public hearing by an independent
and impartial tribunal."
These principals
are not being respected in the case of Mr. Charkaoui, and several others who
find themselves under similar circumstances who are charged with "secret
evidence."
If CSIS can knock
on my door in the dead of night, haul me away and say they have secret evidence
against me which I or my lawyer are not allowed to see, then as far as I am
concerned allowing this to happen is a threat to Canada's national security. No
one will be safe in this country as we make this slippery descent into
barbarism…”
“…all those living
in Canada are under attack, and that should be a cause of concern for all
Canadians.
It is Charkaoui
today, but who knows, maybe it will be you tomorrow…”
In the Montreal Gazette under Security handcuffs defence
JAMES MENNIE wrote
“…They had Adil
Charkaoui in handcuffs when they brought him into Room 3.06, but after a few
minutes you got the impression it was the court whose hands were tied…”
“…Federal Court
Justice Simon Noël looked out at the courtroom and brought everyone up to
speed. Noël explained how "the legislators" obliged him to review the
federal government's case against Charkaoui within 48 hours of the latter's
arrest. He explained he had seven days to review whatever information the
government could provide to back up its claim that the quiet-looking…” “…Noël
explained to the McGill St. courtroom it was his duty to make sure the process
of addressing the government's case against Charkaoui be conducted in an
expedient manner. He also said how important it was that Charkaoui be made
aware of the allegations against him.
But as he
approached the part about just what exactly Charkaoui is legally entitled to
know, about just how much of the government case could be made public without
compromising what that same government contends are the interests of national
security, the tempo of Noël's résumé began to slow.
And it was then
that the judge asked himself out loud whether the information he did finally
share with Charkaoui's lawyers was sufficient to their case without
compromising Canada's security.
"And after
some deep reflection and a few sleepless nights, I found the answer was
yes."
“…In a typical criminal
proceeding, the accused is charged by the Crown and it falls to the Crown to
prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt to a judge or a jury. The Crown's case
must be fully disclosed to the defence so the latter can poke and prod and
examine it, because in this country, the rights of the accused are, however
frustratingly on occasion, paramount.
But in Charkaoui's
case, things are different. He has been charged with no crime….” “…a case that
can be summed up by the presiding judge as follows: "The government says
you're a threat to national security and you should be kicked out of the
country. Here's most of their case against you. I can't tell you the rest
because of national security. "So, now, convince me why I shouldn't
believe them."
Justice for Adil Charkoui is justice for all Canada let us fight to
abolish is law and to be all equal in front of normal law of land and not in
the hand of spy agent.
Justice Coalition
For Adil Charkoui is
calling for all people to show up on support for a due process on his bail
hearing that set for July 2nd at he Montreal court 80 McGill street
at 9:00 AM
Justice Coalition
For Adil Charkaoui could be reach in Toronto the Campaign to Stop Secret Trials
in Canada at (416) 651-5800, and by e-mail at: justiceforadil@riseup.net And all
information are available at Montreal Muslim News www.adilinfo.org
Now
we all know that under the security certificate,
secret evidence could be used against any of us, which neither you nor your
lawyer is allowed to see? And they could condemn you with no right to appeal!
So I think this is
the time to move, to resist this injustice and to move all of us to support
this coalition and to call for abolishing this law, this needs effort and
money; time has come that all civil social organization set a side a small
percentage of their budget and activities for the well being of all population
politically.
Please read and feel free to forward, print, and publish.
We would like to apologize fro any repeated
messages, and any typing or grammatical errors.
We act because we believe in this quote: ”
You can fool some people some time, but you cannot fool all people all time”
Mohamed S. Kamel
internationalnews-owner@yahoogroups.com
www.apm-ram.com
Disclaimer
We are committed to free knowledge, unless
otherwise indicated, the opinions, personal articles or news analysis expressed
on this e-mails are not necessarily those of the sender. This e-mail has been
compiled in good faith. It is our condition that, in exchange for this free
information, you the receiver accept that we will not be liable for any action
you, the user take based on the information in this e-mail. It is essential
that you, the user verify any and/or all information contained herein before
making your final decision. This e-mail does not necessarily endorse the ideas
or presentation of ideas of the sites it links to and with. We make no
representations about any linked web site's accuracy, completeness, and
authenticity. We firmly believe in the Freedom of Speech. We believe in
civilized exchange of ideas and thoughts. We will hold any one trying to damage
our image legally responsible before the courts and will keep ourselves the
right to pursue the perpetrators to the maximum law limit. If you do not agree
with this disclaimer or would like to stop receiving our e-mails, please
unsubscribe, if you find that this e-mail is a good source of knowledge and would
like to invite any others, please feel free.
